Save the tigers? It may be too late
Wednesday , July 09, 2014 - 2:02 PM
Photojournalist Steve Winter spent a decade photographing tigers in the wild in Asia. In 2007, when his life partner, writer Sharon Guynup, joined him for an assignment in India's Kaziranga National Park, they both came away concerned about the fate of these great animals. A century ago, more than 100,000 tigers roamed across 24 Asian countries, from Turkey to Indonesia. Today, they have disappeared from most of their historic range, and poaching, deforestation and a huge Chinese market for tiger parts (which are used in traditional Chinese medicine and as luxury items) have reduced their numbers to no more than 3,200. "We realized that tigers are almost gone, and no one seems to recognize that," Guynup said. The couple have collaborated on a book, "Tigers Forever," that combines magnificent images of the wild animals with troubling text about their dwindling state. Guynup said they hope it will shock the world into doing something "before the tigers are gone." The two recently spoke by telephone with The Post from their home in New Jersey on what it will take to save the world's biggest cat.
Q: Americans often assume that tigers are protected. How have conservation efforts failed?
A: Guynup: Because big conservation organizations have such huge fundraising needs and large administrative costs, their message to the public is often "We're saving tigers, we're saving polar bears." I think that message has lulled the public into believing that we're actually making progress. The biggest downfall of every large conservation organization today is that they are not addressing the demand [for tiger parts]. Unless the demand from China is stopped, tigers won't survive very far into the future. The organizations that are addressing the demand are the Wildlife Protection Society of India, the Environmental Investigation Agency based in London and WildAid, based here in the United States. Those are smaller, investigative, nimble organizations, and they're on the ground doing the undercover investigative work showing what's happening. And the combination of legal tiger farms in China, where they can legally sell skins, and an ongoing trade in tiger bone for tiger bone wine [believed to cure arthritis and impart strength, among other things] is killing the wild tigers across their range.
Q: Are those sales to China the biggest threat to tigers?
A: Guynup: Poaching has really skyrocketed, and it's fueled by the legal trade within China. There was a call by the international community in 2007 for all tiger-range countries to phase out tiger farming. But China's tiger farms have only grown. As long as those farms exist and there is a legal trade, they will not only stimulate demand but also launder all the wild products.
China argues that they should be able to have tiger farms because it's a domestic issue. But it's not. That demand is killing India's tigers and Thailand's tigers and other countries' tigers.
Winter: Stopping habitat loss is also very important. I saw that in Sumatra. When I first went to Sumatra [which is part of Indonesia] for a tiger story, we thought that [the Sumatran] tiger would be the next subspecies to go extinct. Now, that no longer seems to be the case [because their population appears to be higher than previously estimated].
But there also doesn't seem to be any movement toward protecting whatever land is left and stopping the rampant destruction of the forest for palm oil and wood. The fact that tiger numbers are now understood [to be higher than previously thought] in Sumatra is important. And value has been placed on their continued survival by some important people in Indonesia. For example, one of the country's most influential businessmen, Tomy Winata, has [become interested]. He founded a tiger sanctuary in 1996, which is part of a national park. With effective enforcement and zero tolerance toward poaching, he and his team have successfully secured a significant area.
And Thailand also created [an enforcement project] at the Huai Kha Khaeng Wildlife Sanctuary in 2005 on the Thai-Burma border that has a protection force that is now being mirrored in other South Asia protected areas. But tigers don't exist in viable breeding populations elsewhere except in a few limited locations in India, Sumatra and Siberia.
Guynup: That patrol in Huai Kha Khaeng is a military-style patrol that does a pretty good job of protection [against poachers]. National parks that have tigers living within them need protection the same way cities need police. More than half of the world's remaining wild tigers live in India. The Bengal tigers in India are the biggest hope for tiger survival. But it's a country that is trying to keep an economy cranking at a high level, and there are 1.2 billion people living in India, so there's a fight over resources and land. India is a poaching target because it shares a long, porous border with China. India is where the most tigers are, so that's the source [for many poachers].
Q: Your book chronicles both the thrills and perils of tracking tigers throughout Asia, including dodging a charging rhino and patrolling for poachers with rangers. What was the biggest challenge you faced?
Winter: I think that always the biggest challenge is showing readers something they haven't seen before and creating renewed interest. You would never see a tiger in Sumatra or Thailand without using remote cameras [that trigger photographs when animals walk by], and because of the way I use remote cameras with artificial lights that balance with the daylight, I sometimes get pictures that people think look fake. Or they just stop when they see them. Which is great, because even if someone says, "Wow, that looks unreal," they've just spent five seconds longer on that picture than they normally would.
Because people are inundated with images 24/7, my job is to find a different way to photograph tigers, not just from the top of an elephant or in a jeep, but eye to eye with these intimate portraits that I'm able to get through the camera traps. But it's very dangerous because you're on the ground. In Kaziranga, I was filled with tension every time I exited the jeep to check the traps, because there are other animals like rhinos and elephants around, and you're entering their territory on your feet.
Q: And then you faced some challenges when you came home. Hurricane Sandy hit just as you began pulling this book together, and you were forced to evacuate your house.
Guynup: It affected me more than Steve because I was starting to research and write the book on a very, very short deadline. I did my first overnight Skype interviews to Asia from a Super 8 motel where we stayed for about 10 days with our 90-pound Lab, our four-month-old puppy, the cat, my adult son and Steve and I, so that was a little crazy. Steve lost 20 years of field gear, and we lost lots of personal stuff. Our home wasn't ruined, but we had huge storage in the basement that included prints and original slides.
Q: The book includes spectacular photographs of wild tigers, but it also includes disturbing images of poachers, traps and other animals. Why?
Winter: I've found two ways to overcome information overload. Number One is showing people images they haven't seen before and Number Two is showing images that might be a bit disturbing. So they look at them and hopefully they will find out the story behind the photograph. I also looked at Kaziranga as a kind of historic landscape where tigers live with species as in centuries past. This is what it used to look like and still does in a few select locations. It's great to see intact ecosystems that are protected with a variety of animals that are in them.
Guynup: Steve began his career as a photojournalist. So when he photographs wildlife, he approaches his assignments as a photojournalist. Unless you're going to tell the whole story and show people why these animals are disappearing and get them to care and hopefully to act, all the pretty pictures in the world aren't going to save these animals.
Q: What else should be done to help save tigers?
Guynup: The international community needs to join together and pressure China to stop the sale of tiger parts, skins, bones, all tiger parts from all sources, both captive and wild. And tiger-range countries need to use tools that are available through Interpol and other international agreements, to step up enforcement. If the demand is stopped, if the tiger farms are phased out and enforcement steps up, we can save tigers. But if that doesn't happen, they're going to disappear, possibly within our lifetime. People might think, "Oh, farms: Well, that kind of takes care of it all, and then we'll put them back." But once tigers have been in captivity and in contact with people, they're too dangerous to put back into the wild.
There are heavy population pressures in Asia, but India has over 40 tiger reserves. There's plenty of land. And now many areas are working to set up corridors to connect these reserves, so that the populations don't become inbred. As long as tigers have habitat, food and protection, they're a very resilient species. They bounce back. There is hope.
— — —
Popular in Environment
WARREN — A potential showdown between Weber County and one of its residents appears to have been avoided after the signing of an easement agreement late...
WASHINGTON — The American public and U.S. scientists are light-years apart on science issues. And 98 percent of surveyed scientists say it’s a problem...