Editorial

The naked gun

OUR VIEW: Firearm bill unnecessary

Davis County state Rep. Paul Ray, R-Clinton, is sponsoring a bill to allow people to legally carry a firearm without fear of being charged with disorderly conduct by police. It's a bad idea that takes away important aspects of a law enforcement officer's job, such as the ability to discern when an incident can get out of hand, and the ability to control a tense situation.

Rep. Ray is apparently worried about a law enforcement officer's hassling a law-abiding individual who is legally carrying a firearm. On the very rare ocacasions that occurs, we share his concern.

But Rep. Ray's House Bill 49 is not needed to address a rare problem. We're far more worried about police officers being legislatively forced to mull over whether they are breaking an unnecessary firearms law while trying to defuse or deal with a tense, dangerous situation.

Frankly, if one is allowed to legally carry a firearm in Utah, they should be mature enough to comply with an officer's request and then file a complaint later if so inclined.

We don't see a rash of cases where police have hassled owners of firearms in Utah. Why in the world would the Legislature want to waste time and money creating a law that fulfills no real need?

Love and war

OUR VIEW: Government, marriage and divorce

We don't approve of the government mandating, in this case through the Utah Legislature, that couples take required courses before getting married or divorced.

Unfortunately, proposals have circulated this legislative session to do that. Ogden Republican Rep. Dixon Pitcher wants to require all couples that want to marry in Utah, take pre-marital counseling of at least three hours. Rep. Jim Nielson, R-Bountiful, wants to require couples with children to take a divorce orientation course before a divorce is filed.

Currently in Utah, couples are required to complete a divorce orientation course before the divorce is finalized.

Priceless permission

OUR VIEW: More liquor licenses needed

State Rep. Gage Froerer, R-Huntsville, is one of the more sensible pols in the Top of Utah. He has attempted more than once to undo legislative damage created by his colleagues in the majority party. Froerer's latest cleanup attempt is House Bill 270, which would significantly increase the number of liquor licenses provided to Utah restaurants.

We urge the Legislature to pass HB270 quickly and hope Gov. Gary Herbert signs it into law. It's always been a source of embarrassment and shame that members of the dominant political party have set the quota of liquor licenses allowed to Utah restaurants so low. The number of licenses is based on state population. Froerer's bill changes that so more licenses can be issued.

Because so few licenses are issued, there are many businesses that can't get licenses. This decreases the number of new restaurants that might be initiated in areas outside of Salt Lake City. Entrepreneurs are less likely to start restaurants here if they can't have a liquor license so persons enjoying a meal can have the right to enjoy an alcoholic drink.

Ashes

OUR VIEW: Josh Powell's evil is banal

After Josh Powell murdered his two sons on Sunday, as well as killing himself in the process, Pierce County, Washington, Sheriff Paul Pastor summed it up best. "What happened here was an act of evil. Do not call it a tragedy because that sanitizes it. This was a terrible act of murder involving two young children," he said."

The murder of Charlie and Braden Powell affects most of us so much because it's a horrible part of a larger story that has consumed Utahns for 26 months. In December 2009, Susan Powell disappeared from her West Valley home. Her husband, Josh Powell was always considered the only person of interest in the case. After he moved to Washington, the case involved a lengthy custody dispute with his missing spouse's family. After Josh Powell's latest legal setback in that dispute, in which he was ordered to submit to a psychosexual evaluation and polygraph exam. On Sunday, after receiving his two boys as part of a supervised visitation, he pushed a social worker out of his home, locked himself and the boys inside, and set fire to the home. Autopsies show the boys suffered "chop injuries," which indicates the vicious nature of the crime.

Toddler tantrum

OUR VIEW: Lee's headless charge

Like a chicken with its head sliced off, Utah's junior senator is charging in opposition to President Barack Obama's presidential nominations. Mike Lee has vowed to oppose every nominee that Obama presents before the U.S. Senate for approval.

Lee is angry that the president has bypassed accepted Senate custom by appointing nominees when the Senate is in "pro forma" sessions three days apart to stop presidents from appointing nominees that the Senate has blocked. What this means is that Republicans in the Senate are using filibusters to prevent Obama from getting his nominees through.

This is all a technical and legal argument. It needs to be worked out either between the opposing sides -- Democrats and Republicans -- or through the courts. And that latter option will likely come soon. Republicans are challenging Obama's recent appointments.

OUR VIEW: Thumbs up, thumbs down

Thumbs up: To volunteers who are "human books" at Utah State University's Merrill-Cazier Library. We think it's cool that individual with expertise on distinct subjects can be "checked out" by patrons and provide information to library users.

Thumbs down: To a would-be Ogden area tagger who explained to police who caught him in the act that he was hoping his graffiti would help him get a job as a graphic artist. Try a resume, sir, and hope there isn't a background check.

My eyes!!!!

OUR VIEW: Herrod's folly

Rep. Chris Herrod, R-Provo, is using his position in the state Legislature to waste everyone's time with an immigration bill, HB300, that would stop funding and end the Peace Officers Standards and Training certification for Utah police chiefs who choose not to enforce immigration statutes.

Herrod is running for the U.S. Senate, where a malicious folly such as House Bill 300 might appeal to a few ultra-conservative state delegates who regard illegal immigration as the most important issue in the U.S. today. The rest of us see Herrod's proposal for what it is -- another example of a groveling pol wasting time and money on an issue that for now is in the hand of the courts.

One person Herrod is obviously targeting is Salt Lake City Police Chief Chris Burbank, who is opposed to having local police enforce immigration laws. Herrod's shot at Burbank and other chiefs will have little chance of being sensible until the U.S. Supreme Court rules on states' efforts to enforce immigration laws. There are several working their way through judicial channels, including laws in Utah, Arizona and Alabama. So we urge the Legislature to ignore HB300 for now. There are more important issues to deal with.

Sudden impact

OUR VIEW: Aubree Jo's law

We support what is being called "Aubree Jo's law," a bill from state Rep. Ryan Wilcox, R-Ogden, which would adjust child custody laws to also specifically consider the best interest of the child.

Wilcox's bill, HB88, adds one line to the custody amendment. That line reads, "In determining any form of custody, the court may not discriminate against a parent due to gender, race, religious preference, or age, but shall consider the best interests of the child."

The genesis for HB88, and why it is called "Aubree Jo's law," refers to the tragic death of Top of Utah toddler, Aubree Jo Anderson, who died last year, on Feb. 23, as a result of injuries in a traffic accident in which her mother, Brandi Stilke, survived but suffered head injuries.

Stilke later pleaded guilty to negligent operation of a vehicle to cause the death of her daughter. She is serving a term of up to 15 years in the Utah State Prison.

Pennies from heaven

OUR VIEW: Privacy and drug tests

State Rep. Brad Wilson, R-Kaysville, wants applicants who file for financial assistance from the Division of Workforce Services to be required to submit to a written test to determine if they have a substance abuse problem. It's a bad idea and shouldn't progress in the Legislature.

We regard the test as an intrusion into applicants' privacy, and also an unfair insinuation that a significant percentage of persons who need economic assistance are in that situation due to personal bad habits. We'd advise Wilson and other legislators to take a look at developments in Florida, where a judge has blocked efforts to drug-test welfare applicants in that state. A judge agreed that forcing a drug test on applicant, Luis W. Lebron, 35, a veteran, was unconstitutional.

Tick, tick, tick

OUR VIEW: A foiled bomb plot

We give thanks to all those who helped alert police to an alleged plot to bomb Roy High School during an assembly at the school. Two students are accused of the plot. We are fortunate that in this circumstance, we are in an environment where persons who learned of the plot felt compelled to come forward and alert authorities of the alleged plot.

In an era that still haunts with the memory of the massacre at Columbine High School, murderous plans by teens must be reported and responded to. Dark fantasies may end with plotting and daydreams, or they may be the beginning of murder. To ignore text messages and other clues that point to mayhem is a deadly threat that would be criminal to ignore.

Professor Web

OUR VIEW: A thing about machines

In an amusing episode of "The Simpsons," Lisa Simpson, playing the bad girl, steals all the teachers' editions of the school books. Mass chaos and panic ensues, with one teacher wailing, "WHO KNOWS THE MULTIPLICATION TABLES??" It's a funny line, and could be repeated today if the Internet ceased to exist. One imagines students digging for long-discarded encyclopedias or simply curling up in a fetal-like ball if deprived of technological research tools such as Google or even Wikipedia.

We can do research and communicate today in ways that only 20 to 30 years ago would have been portrayed in science fiction. With the Internet technology era, we can expand the length and depth of knowledge more easily; but can that same technology stunt our intellectual growth? In other words, "Are Machines Making Us Stupid?" That's the title of a new class at Weber State University, and it's a fascinating question. In the class, students are observed and tested for how they gather information with total Internet access, with limited online access, and no Web access.

Stinky diaper

OUR VIEW: Strange 'ethics' for Utah pols

Another legislative session in Utah brings another needed call for better ethics. Utah legislators have made tiny, baby steps toward ethics reform within the past couple of years, but they still fall short.

The most notable practice by the Legislature is its failure to enact campaign finance limits. A legislator can gobble up all the campaign cash he or she desires from special interests.

Also, legislators are allowed to use some of their campaign funds for personal stuff, or as gifts to other legislators.

This is not what the public thought they were getting when legislators told us they had "accomplished" ethics reforms.

OUR VIEW: Thumbs up, thumbs down

Thumbs up: To the destruction of chemical weapons that had been stored in the Utah desert for decades. At the Chemical Agent Disposal Facility, Deseret Chemical Depot, near Tooele, employees recently finished the task by destroying the blister agent, lewisite.

Thumbs down: To our expanding girths in America. More than one-third of adults are considered obese, a disturbing statistic that has not changed since 2003. About 17 percent of children are obese.

Canal days

OUR VIEW: Share the canal costs

We agree with Pleasant View Mayor Doug Clifford and other area leaders that three cities, Pleasant View, North Ogden and Ogden, should get together and reach an agreement for cleaning and maintenance of the canals that run through the three cities.

All of the cities use the canal. They carry stormwater and irrigation for agriculture. Silt that gathers at the dirt canals is an expensive problem, as is the growth and needed trimming of trees and other natural hazards to the canals. Property owners no longer have the responsibility to maintain canals on their property.

Slam dunk

OUR VIEW: Economic fairness

In his State of the Union address on Tuesday night, President Barack Obama called for economic fairness, which he and the Democrats define as using government to reduce the gap between the very rich and middle class. The president unveiled a list of measures the administration will pitch to Congress. Given the current hostility between Republicans and Democrats, only a few will likely be successful. In fact, Republicans had nothing but criticism for the president's speech.

That's not a surprise; Democrats were never known to respond to former President George W. Bush's proposals with enthusiasm. But the divisive response to the latest State of the Union address is not encouraging to future bipartisanship, or accomplishments.

Proposals that have a chance to receive bipartisan support include eliminating tax breaks for corporations that move jobs out of the country. Also, incentives for job-related investments within the United States we imagine will be popular.

Advertisement
  +

Recent Comments

Latest Blogs

Blogging the Rambler
Leg fighting Clear Air? So much for common sense
By: Charles Trentelman

Friday, February 10, 2012 - 4:34pm

The Political Surf
Judges are tailoring gay marriage opinion to appeal to...
By: Doug Gibson

Wednesday, February 8, 2012 - 2:36pm

Me, myself... as mommy
Death call
By: MeganSanders

Tuesday, January 31, 2012 - 2:53pm

Why Are You Crying?
No economic crisis in college football
By: Mark Shenefelt

Monday, December 12, 2011 - 11:36am

Standard-Examiner Sports Blogs
Jazz release statement from Sloan to Yahoo! Sports
By: Jim Burton

Saturday, February 4, 2012 - 12:49pm

Latest Tweets



Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement


Advertisement

Online Polls

How does all the recent violent, crime news make you feel?