×
×
homepage logo

Ask Dr. Steve: Feeling down lately? One question that reveals if it’s depression or just a bad situation

By Steven Szykula, PhD and Jason Sadora, CMHC - Special to the Standard-Examiner | Sep 13, 2025

Photo supplied

Steven A. Szykula

Everyone feels down sometimes. Bad weeks happen — disappointments pile up, energy drops, and life feels harder than usual. But when does normal sad or down feelings become clinical depression?

The line between temporary low mood and depression isn’t always clear. Many people struggle for months, wondering if they’re “depressed enough” to seek help, while others panic over normal emotional responses to life’s challenges. Knowing the difference isn’t just academic–it determines whether you need professional treatment or simply time off and self-care.

Depression is one of the most treatable mental health conditions, yet most people wait over a year before seeking help. Don’t Wait.

Understanding Depression vs. Normal Sadness

Q: What’s the one question that reveals if it’s depression?

A: “Has this persisted for more than two weeks AND significantly impaired your ability to function in work, relationships, or daily activities?” Normal sadness, even intense grief, comes in waves and doesn’t completely disable functioning. Depression is persistent (lasting most of the day, nearly every day) and impairs multiple life areas. If you’ve been unable to work effectively, maintain relationships, or manage basic self-care for over two weeks, it’s likely depression. You should seek professional help.

Q: What are the physical signs that separate depression from sadness?

A: Depression manifests physically in ways sadness doesn’t. Look for sleep changes (insomnia or hypersomnia), appetite disruption (loss or significant increase), psychomotor changes (feeling slowed down or agitated), and persistent fatigue despite rest. These biological symptoms persist regardless of circumstances–even good news doesn’t give you a lift.

Q: Why does depression feel different from being sad?

A: Depression involves anhedonia — the inability to feel pleasure in previously enjoyable activities. It’s not just feeling sad; it’s feeling nothing. Patients describe it as “emotional numbness” or “going through motions.” Local therapists report this distinction helps clients recognize when they need treatment versus support.

Q: Can you have depression without feeling sad?

A: Yes. Many people, especially men, experience depression as irritability, anger, or have physical symptoms rather than sadness. Some report feeling “empty” rather than sad. About 30% of men diagnosed depression cases don’t report sadness as primary symptom.

Q: How quickly can normal sadness turn into depression?

A: While diagnostic criteria require two weeks of symptoms, the shift often happens gradually over 4-6 weeks. Stressful life events trigger normal sadness, but if coping mechanisms fail and biological vulnerabilities exist, it can cascade into depression. Early intervention during this transition period is most effective.

Q: What’s the difference between grief and depression?

A: Grief comes in waves, often triggered by reminders of loss. Between waves, you can experience positive emotions. Depression is constant. When one is grieving one maintains self-esteem, while if depressed, depression destroys self-esteem. Grief thoughts focus on the deceased; depression thoughts focus on personal worthlessness. Complicated grief (grief becoming depression) affects about 10% of bereaved individuals.

Q: Why do some people get depression while others just feel sad?

A: Depression vulnerability involves genetic factors (40% heritability), early life experiences, current stress, and biological factors like inflammation or hormonal changes. Two people experiencing identical stressors may have completely different responses based on these vulnerability factors. Comprehensive evaluation can identify individual risk factors.

Q: What happens in the brain during depression?

A: Depression involves reduced activity in the prefrontal cortex (affecting decision-making), hippocampal shrinkage (impacting memory), and altered neurotransmitter function (serotonin, dopamine, norepinephrine). These changes explain why “just thinking positive” doesn’t work–the brain structures needed for mood regulation are impaired.

Q: Can mild depression become severe if untreated?

A: Yes. Untreated depression typically worsens over 6-12 months. Each depressive episode makes future episodes more likely and severe — a phenomenon called “kindling.” First episodes average 3-6 months untreated; recurrent episodes last longer. Early treatment prevents this progression.

Q: How can I tell if my teenager is depressed or just moody?

A: Teen depression often presents as irritability, academic decline, social withdrawal, and sleep changes lasting over two weeks. Normal teen moodiness fluctuates; depression is consistent. If grades drop significantly, friendships end, or self-harm thoughts emerge, it’s beyond normal adolescent adjustment. Utah School District report increased rates of depression in their students.

Q: What’s “high-functioning depression”?

A: Persistent depressive disorder (dysthymia) involves chronic low-grade depression where people maintain basic functioning but live far below their potential. They work, maintain relationships, but everything requires enormous effort. Many don’t seek help because they’re “managing,” not recognizing they could feel significantly better.

Q: Can depression really be treated in 8-12 sessions?

A: Mild to moderate depression often responds well to 8-12 sessions of cognitive-behavioral therapy or interpersonal therapy. Severe depression may require longer treatment episodes of care and/or medication. Research shows 60-70% of people experience significant improvement with appropriate treatment. The key is accurate assessment to determine severity and best treatment approach.

Q: Should I try to handle depression myself ?

A: For mild symptoms lasting under three weeks, self-care (exercise, sleep hygiene, social support) may help. But if symptoms meet depression criteria — two weeks of persistent symptoms with functional impairment — professional help is warranted. Waiting typically worsens outcomes. It’s like having diabetes; you wouldn’t try managing it alone.

Q: When is emergency help needed for depression?

A: Seek immediate help if experiencing suicidal thoughts, self-harm urges, or complete inability to function. Utah based crisis services report that early intervention during severe episodes prevents hospitalization in 70% of cases. Having a crisis plan before reaching this point is ideal.

Q: How do I know if I need medication versus therapy?

A: Moderate to severe depression often benefits from combined treatment. Mild depression typically responds to therapy alone. Factors like previous episodes, family history, and symptom severity guide treatment decisions. Comprehensive psychological evaluation can determine optimal treatment approach, considering your specific symptoms, history, and preferences.

Closing

The difference between normal sadness, low mood and depression isn’t just duration–it’s the pervasive impairment that steals your ability to function and feel. That one crucial question–has this persisted over two weeks AND significantly impaired functioning–draws the line between needing support versus needing treatment.

Depression often convinces you that seeking help is pointless, that you should be stronger, or that you don’t deserve to feel better. These thoughts are symptoms, not truths. Depression is a medical condition requiring treatment, not a character flaw requiring willpower.

If you’ve been wondering whether your low mood is “bad enough” to address, you likely already have your answer. The fact that you’re questioning it suggests impact beyond normal sadness. Don’t wait for it to get worse–depression is most treatable when caught early.

Remember: Depression lies to you. It tells you things won’t improve, that you’re alone, that help won’t work. Evidence proves otherwise. With proper assessment and treatment, most people experience significant relief from there depression within weeks. You don’t have to live with the weight of depression.

For those concerned about depression or mood changes, comprehensive psychological evaluation can clarify diagnosis and guide treatment. Comprehensive Psychological Services (WeCanHelpOut.com) with clinics near you offers evidence-based assessment and treatment, helping distinguish between normal life challenges and clinical conditions requiring intervention.

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today