×
×
homepage logo

Fischer: For unforthcoming seller, when it rains it might just pour

By Jen Fischer - Special to the Standard-Examiner | Sep 29, 2023

Photo supplied

Jen Fischer

While we are all so grateful for the abundance of moisture we have received this past year (taken right from the mouth of the people in the pews), I think I can speak for everyone when I say that no one wants to find themselves in deep water. However, thanks to a failure to disclose a material fact about a specific home, that is exactly where my clients found themselves after the most recent rainstorm.

​The 16-page legal form “Seller’s Property Condition Disclosure” is a required form in any Utah real estate transaction. The form states on Page 1, “Seller is obligated under law and under REPC section 7(a), regardless of occupancy, to disclose to buyers, defects in the property and facts known to seller that materially and adversely affect the use and value of the property that cannot be discovered by a reasonable inspection by an ordinary prudent buyer.” The form then goes on to ask a series of very specific questions that would be blatantly relevant to the buyers, including an entire section on moisture-related conditions. In other words, there is ample opportunity to disclose anything and everything relating to water having been someplace where it should not have been in the home. In this case, the boxes were marked “no” and the blanks were left open.

​Imagine then my buyers’ surprise when it began raining last week and water came gushing in through the main window in the living room. Although the rainstorm wasn’t torrential, the water coming into their home was. To be fair, we had noticed excessive amounts of poorly applied caulking around the exterior of the window at the time of the inspection walk-through. The inspector had told us that there appeared to have been evidence of previous water intrusion at the window into the home. Why then, pray tell, was this not in the disclosures? These were the original owners of the home, which they had built themselves. Surely, if there had been some water intrusion, they would have known about it. I called the list agent to ask. She said she would call the owners and get back to me.

​As a side note: As the list agent, all we can do is implore our sellers to be completely transparent on the disclosures. We cannot help them fill it out, nor can we fill it out for them. We simply advise them to disclose any and all material defects and answer all questions honestly and with as much detail as necessary. There is even a large blank space at the end of the disclosures for any overflow text. In fact, there is an additional addendum that has been provided for Realtors, lest there be something that may have been “accidentally” omitted or if something happens to the home after the disclosures were signed. While I had complete confidence that the agent did her job, I was hesitant about the seller having done his.

​The seller told her that the first year they lived there, there was a snowstorm, and a snow drift was on the roof, and when it melted a couple of drops snuck through, so they caulked it really well to be sure nothing else happened. “A couple of drops? Snuck? Is snuck even a word?” These were all questions running through my head. Either way, those two drops should have been mentioned on the disclosures, especially since there was clear evidence, at this point, that it was far more than “a couple of drops.” Either way, we wrote up a repair addendum asking for a stucco and roofing contractor to fix this issue that the seller clearly had “no idea about.” They agreed and provided “proof” it had been addressed. We had no reason to think otherwise so we closed on the property.

​Back to the situation at hand, my buyers were now dealing with an active water issue. I recommended they call my disaster cleanup contractor, as he is an expert in all things related to water intrusion. He came out immediately. He diagnosed the problem as improper flashing around the windows and quoted several thousand dollars to fix it. He said there was clear evidence that this had been an issue before and the copious amounts of caulking around the windows to “fix it” had resulted in making the problem worse and trapping the water instead of letting it run out, which resulted in the water gushing through the window.

​Just for fun, let’s take a second look at the top of the disclosure page, specifically the part that states that the “Seller is obligated under law …” What happens when the law is broken? If the seller refuses to pay for a real repair, we will find out exactly what happens. It may not be just the water that is deep for these sellers.

Jen Fischer is an associate broker and Realtor. She can be reached at 801-645-2134 or jen@jen-fischer.com.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox
I'm interested in (please check all that apply)(Required)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper?(Required)

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today