The nation’s largest state has just voted in an election triggered by one of the nation’s weirdest recall processes — and the results have come out just about where they’ve been before.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom was elected governor in 2018 by 62% to 38%, a result that was, unsurprisingly in an era of straight-ticket voting and strong partisan allegiance, almost identical to Joe Biden’s 64% to 34% over Donald Trump in 2020.

As of this writing — and it has taken California weeks to count its votes in recent general elections — incomplete returns show 64% of Californians against recalling Newsom and only 36% in favor of removing him from office.

That result makes the second question on the ballot, who shall replace the governor, irrelevant. But it did enable Democrats to spend enormous sums characterizing Larry Elder, the conservative radio talk host who led in polls on the replacement question, as a clone of Trump.

Some liberals even attacked Elder, who is black, as a “white supremacist.” It’s interesting who plays the race card these days.

Newsom’s success is good news for Democrats. Polls over the summer showed as many as 47% of voters supporting recall. When voters focused on facts, such as the growing homeless encampments and the rapidly rising numbers of homicides and carjackings, they found reason to repudiate the liberal policies that Newsom has pursued or supported.

Newsom’s appearance, maskless, at the expensive ($350 a plate) French Laundry restaurant, celebrating the birthday of a Democratic lobbyist, was an unforced error, perhaps characteristic of a politician whose core constituency has been San Francisco billionaires.

But an avalanche of TV ads targeting Trump got voters thinking in partisan terms, with the results as noted. Go over the county maps of the 2018, 2020, and 2021 contests and see how the results are the same within a couple of points just about everywhere.

The exit polls, however, suggest some shifts among demographic groups. Recall was opposed by 81% of black voters, who are only 6% of California’s population, but by significantly fewer Asians, with 62%, and Latinos, with 58%.

These latter “people of color” groups were less supportive of Newsom than white college graduates (68%). This reflects the increasing dominance in the Democratic Party of white college graduates and the fact that on issues, they are often the party’s leftmost group.

White voters without college degrees, or those left behind after hundreds of thousands of others have abandoned California’s high housing and energy costs, were the one ethnically defined group that favored recall, 57% to 43%.

These results mirror the recent national Quinnipiac University Poll that shows approval of Biden nationally at just 42%. Approval is 69% among black people and 56% among white college graduates, but it’s only 38% among Hispanics and 28% among white people who didn’t attend college.

That polarization seems to be increasing. MSNBC’s Steve Kornacki compared the 2018 and 2021 Newsom exit poll numbers and found that his support has risen by 9 points among white college graduates but declined by 12 points among noncollege white voters and 6 points among Hispanics. That looks much like the changes that occurred nationally between the 2016 and 2020 presidential elections.

California, which seemed a harbinger of the political future from the 1950s through the 1980s, is clearly not so anymore. It was the second best state, after Hawaii, for Hillary Clinton in 2016 — the fifth best, after Vermont, Massachusetts, Maryland, and Hawaii, for Biden in 2020.

Nor does California seem to be the demographic wave of the future. Forty years ago, I was writing about the dynamic economic growth on both sides of the Pacific Rim, in California and Japan. In the 1990s and 2000s, I substituted China for Japan and saluted California’s booming high tech and China’s double-digit economic growth.

Now the flowers on both sides of the Pacific Rim seem to be wilting. Thanks to its recently repealed one-child policy, China’s workforce is now shrinking, while California’s poverty rate, 15%, is the highest in the nation when cost of living is taken into account . Illegal immigrants, who headed mostly to California 20 years ago, are mostly heading to Texas now.

After two decades of domestic population outflow, the 2020 census showed California gaining population at less than the national rate since 2010, and in the reapportionment following the census, it lost a congressional seat, and hence an electoral vote, for the first time since it was admitted to the Union in 1850.

Newsom’s victory shows that California voters want more of the same. As H. L. Mencken put it, they deserve to get it good and hard .

Newsletter