×
×
homepage logo

Attorney seeks to expunge teacher’s arrest record

By Loretta Park Standard-Examiner Staff - | Oct 3, 2014

FARMINGTON — A judge is being asked to expunge the arrest record of a former Northridge High School social studies teacher who was accused of but never charged with having an illegal sexual relationship with one of her students 10 years ago. 

Defense attorney Ed Brass filed the motion with 2nd District Court for Chaarie Lynn Jaramillo, 36. Arguments will be heard at 9 a.m. Oct. 16 before Judge Robert Dale. No formal charges have been filed against Jaramillo, according to the court website.

According to the court document filed by Brass, “The state reviewed this case and declined to file charges due to insufficient evidence. Ms. Jaramillio does not pose a threat to the public. Ms. Jaramillo, at present, does not have any pending criminal charges against her. Ms. Jaramillo should not bear the stigma of this arrest on her record.” 

According to the document filed by Brass, it had been “at least 30 days” since Jaramillo was arrested, she has not been arrested for any other charges and no charges were filed against Jaramillo in this case.

He is also asking the judge to order all state, county and local government agencies “to expunge related records in their possession or control,” according to the document.

Jaramillio was arrested on Jan. 22, 2013, following an almost year-long investigation by Layton police. She was booked in the Davis County Jail on three counts of rape and three counts of forcible sex abuse of a 17-year-old. Police said they had received information in February of 2012 about an alleged sexual relationship between Jaramillo and a male student that took place in 2004 when she taught at Northridge High School.

Deputy Davis County Attorney Cristina Ortega filed a statement opposing the request to expunge the arrest record. In the document, Ortega writes the state did not decline to file criminal charges because of insufficient evidence.

“Criminal charges for rape and forcible sodomy were not filed because the statute of limitations had expired,” according to the document. “To the contrary, there was sufficient evidence to file criminal charges.”

The student, who is now an adult, told investigators the sexual relationship with Jaramillo began in March 2004 and ended Aug. 21, 2004, the day before his 18th birthday. 

When law officers interviewed Jaramillo, she “admitted to having sexual intercourse with the alleged victim,” according to the document. 

Prosecutors also argue in the document it is in the public’s best interest not to expunge Jaramillo’s arrest record because she “was a teacher and continued to have a sexual relationship with the aforementioned male student after he graduated from high school.”

Also, the records are relevant and have value “should the petitioner commit a similar sexual offense in the future,” according to the document.

Sex-based cases involving teachers are “unique,” according to the document. The “records are essential records not only for the state but for other entities to be aware of in connection to the petitioner, especially future employment endeavors should they involve minors,” it said.

Jaramillo taught at Granger High School in Granite School District from 2009 to 2012, said Mark Peterson, spokesman with the state Office of Education. She taught at Northridge High School from 2001 to 2009. She began her teaching career at Layton High School.

Peterson said on Friday that Jaramillo has not been employed with any Utah schools since 2012.

Her case at the state Office of Education “is still open and under investigation. It is flagged, which gives notice to anyone who wants to employ her that her case is under investigation.”

Peterson said the state Office of Education conducts its own independent investigation “regardless of what the courts do.”

Contact reporter Loretta Park at 801-625-4252 or lpark@standard.net. Follow her on Twitter at @LorettaParkSE. Like her on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/SELorettaPark.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox
I'm interested in (please check all that apply)(Required)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper?(Required)

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today