×
×
homepage logo

FISCHER: Not everything old needs to be new again

By JEN FISCHER - Special to the Standard-Examiner | Nov 19, 2026

Photo supplied, Jen Fischer

Jen Fischer

There is a photograph hanging on the wall of a home I am currently selling in Ogden. It is a black-and-white photograph of the very house in which I am standing, taken around the time it was built. Snow blankets the ground, and the house stands alone along a stretch of central Ogden.

Today, the neighborhood has grown up around it. Mature trees obscure much of the front of the home, neighboring houses flank either side and cars travel a road that once was paved with dirt and only traveled by horse and buggy. Yet the house remains.

The home is identified by the Ogden City Landmarks Commission, dating construction in 1873. This means the house was standing before Utah was even an official state. By 1870, the railroad was new, having arrived just a couple of years before. This event would dramatically transform Ogden. The city would soon become a significant transportation and commercial hub, bringing new businesses, residents, wealth and a variety of architectural influences. Much of that history remains visible today in the homes that populate Ogden’s older neighborhoods. In fact, this particular home was recently featured in an historic preservation scavenger hunt, an annual event featured by the Ogden City Landmarks Commission, designed to bring attention to the city’s architectural heritage.

I have been entrusted with selling it, the privilege of which is certainly not lost on me. There is, however, a rather significant amount of deferred maintenance. The house needs work. Not the kind of work that can be accomplished over a three-day weekend with a gallon of paint and a YouTube tutorial. It needs some legitimate, substantial repairs. My client, however, is not in a position to undertake those repairs, so we determined early in the process that the home would be sold in its present condition.

Under ordinary circumstances, a property in this condition would generate considerable interest from investors. Many would calculate the cost of acquisition, the cost of renovation, the anticipated resale price and the profit margin necessary to make the project worthwhile. There is nothing inherently wrong with this. It is a business model, and one that can serve a legitimate purpose. My concern was that this particular house could easily be purchased by someone who simply doesn’t understand what they have here.

While we will certainly see a dumpster in front of the property at some point, what would be more than unfortunate would be to strip this home of the architectural integrity. We would tragically lose an irreplaceable part of Ogden’s history. Into that dumpster could go original woodwork, historic windows, architectural details and materials that have somehow managed to survive more than a century only to meet their untimely demise in the interest of making the home look “updated.”. While nothing says historic Ogden quite like gray luxury vinyl plank flooring and a sliding barn door, I wouldn’t be able to sleep at night if this happened.

What initially struck me about this house was how much of its original character remained intact. The tall windows, the proportions of the rooms, the original woodwork, the brick exterior and the architectural lines all reflect a period when homes were constructed with a distinctly different aesthetic and approach to craftsmanship. Is it level? Not at all. But is it a remarkable testament to another era? Absolutely.

Had these features already been removed during some ambitious remodeling project in the 1970s, 1990s or last Tuesday, we would be having an entirely different conversation. But they hadn’t been. This presented an interesting challenge from a real estate perspective. While an investor might look at an original window and deduct the cost of replacing it from an offer, someone experienced in historic restoration might look at the same window and recognize the historic significance and value in preserving it. Same house. Same condition. Entirely different perceptions of value.

Ordinarily, I am a strong advocate of placing a property on the Multiple Listing Service, or MLS. The greater the exposure, the greater the opportunity to generate competition among buyers and, consequently, obtain the best possible price for the seller. Rarely do I recommend limiting that exposure. This was one of those rare occasions.

My client and I discussed both the benefits and potential drawbacks of each approach. Ultimately, we agreed that a more targeted marketing strategy was worth pursuing. The buyer that would generate the most for my client, must be able to see the value in the history and architectural integrity in the home. We went through the appropriate channels to formally exclude the property from the MLS and began reaching out directly to prospective buyers with knowledge of Ogden’s architectural history and experience with historic properties. Our objective was twofold: We wanted to give the home the best possible chance of retaining its architectural integrity while securing the strongest possible financial outcome for my client without requiring her to make repairs.

We weren’t looking for someone willing to overlook the home’s condition. We were looking for someone capable of evaluating its condition without overlooking its value. There is an important distinction there. Certainly, historical significance does not negate the need for a functioning plumbing system, sound electrical wiring, or structural integrity. A house does not get a pass on necessary repairs simply because it was around before the invention of the light bulb. Yet there is a substantial difference between repairing what time has damaged and removing what time has preserved.

I find myself returning to that photograph hanging on the wall. I wonder what the original owners would think if they could stand in front of their house today. The landscape has changed, the street has changed and certainly the cost of real estate has changed. Yet they might still recognize the view from their windows, the woodwork inside their home and the familiar architectural features that have outlasted generations of occupants. I would like to think the next owner of this house will recognize the significance of those things, too.

Jen Fischer is an associate broker and Realtor. She can be reached at 801-645-2134 or jen@jen-fischer.com.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox
I'm interested in (please check all that apply)(Required)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper?(Required)

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today