×
×
homepage logo

Andrews: Three steps forward, two steps back

By Adrienne Andrews - Special to the Standard-Examiner | Aug 23, 2023

Photo supplied, Weber State University

Adrienne Andrews

Hello, friends. It’s me, Adrienne Andrews. It’s been a minute since last we chatted. During that window of time, the Supreme Court overturned affirmative action in college admissions; the Utah System of Higher Education requested a deep dive into the equity, diversity and inclusion efforts of state colleges, universities and technical colleges; and former President Donald J. Trump was indicted on multiple felony charges. I guess Ferris Bueller had it right: “Life moves pretty fast. If you don’t stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it.”

To that end, my amazing father, James H. Gillespie Jr., made all the members of our family stop and look around when he had brain surgery in early July. He’s doing great. The surgical team at the University of Utah did a terrific job putting in a shunt and completing what my sisters and I agree is “Star Trek”-style medicine to address adult-onset hydrocephalus. This wasn’t on our summer Bingo cards, yet the summer continued.

Rather than slowing down, things continued to speed up, and while I would love to write about first days of school (my kiddo started kindergarten — where did that time go?), I’m going to step back and reflect on the end of affirmative action as we knew it, and then a thought or two about the U.S. presidency.

First, affirmative action — what was it?

Affirmative action was President John F. Kennedy’s response to the Civil Rights Movement by way of creating the Committee on Equal Employment Opportunity in 1961. He issued Executive Order 10925, which used the term “affirmative action” to refer to measures designed to achieve nondiscrimination.

In this way, according to the U.S. Department of Labor, affirmative action was a program of positive action undertaken with conviction and effort to overcome the present effects of past practices, policies or barriers to equal employment opportunity and to achieve the full and fair participation of women, minorities and individuals with disabilities found to be underutilized in the workforce based on availability.

The goal was to increase workplace and educational opportunities for people who had been underrepresented in various areas of our society. It focused on demographics with historically low representation in leadership and professional roles. It recognized that, without positive action taken, it would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for all people to succeed or achieve the American dream.

The policy’s intention was laudable, allowing the U.S. to recognize the impacts of racism, classism, sexism and ableism by doing better — because we knew better. The impacts of slavery, Jim Crow, sundown laws, limited voting rights, redlining, and segregation in the military, housing and education could be corrected cleanly.

But doing better for all felt like a loss to people who were perfectly happy with the status quo. I realize that if there are five of us and we agree to split a pie and then you add another two or three people to the mix, we might get upset that our slices got smaller. However, we weren’t dealing with pie then, or now. We’re dealing with humanity. I think that sometimes we forget that, or at least who that includes. For those who are unsure, it means all of us. Every single one of us.

Anyhow, the Supreme Court’s ruling that colleges and universities could no longer take race into consideration as a specific basis for granting admission was a landmark decision because it overturned long-standing precedent that benefited Black and Latino students in higher education. The benefit had been slow moving and the resistance to it lackluster until people began to understand what demographic changes could mean to our states and across our nation.

With this ruling, the signal went from building equality of opportunity to “equal opportunity is somehow potentially racist and removing opportunities for others.”

I digress.

An interesting point to consider: The ruling did away with using race selections in higher education, but it did not address the practice of admitting legacy students — those who are admitted to colleges and universities on the basis of their familial relationship to alumni. Schools such as Harvard consider legacy status in the same way that they used race or other student characteristics to foster a healthy and varied campus community and alumni network.

I digress.

While waiting for the Utah System of Higher Education report on the equity, diversity and inclusion work, which each institution engages in to fulfill their legislative mandates, I’m on tenterhooks. I’m optimistic that our education system and legislative leaders can find common ground as we all seek an educated population that has the skills to fill new and innovative positions to meet employer demands. I’m also hopeful that we consider new tools and measures to assess what is necessary for Utah to remain a top state for innovation, industry and employment.

This leaves me with the presidency. I do not have to like a president to respect the office of the president and the weight of the mantle with which it is endowed. There will always be a significant group of people who are unhappy with our leader and that is OK. What is necessary is that the office or position is not attacked. We are human, after all.

Adrienne Andrews is the vice president of Equity, Diversity and Inclusion at Weber State University. Twitter: AdieAndrewsCDO.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox
I'm interested in (please check all that apply)(Required)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper?(Required)

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today