Guest opinion: Dangerous highways in Utah if congressional effort prevails
Utah highways will get a lot more dangerous if shipping companies are successful in persuading Congress to raise the weigh limits of tractor trailers.
It seems like a simple, undeniable fact to most people that bigger semi-trucks would be deadlier and more damaging to our roads than the current trucks on the road, yet lawmakers currently are pushing proposals that would put public safety at risk.
As someone who witnesses the reality of traffic in Spanish Fork from the congestion at our I-15 interchanges to the steady flow of freight navigating US-6, it is crucial that we examine the implications of these proposed changes for our families and our infrastructure.
At issue are two proposals included as part of the BUILD America 250 Act — both of which introduce heavier, more dangerous commercial trucks.
First is a 10-year “pilot project” that would allow states to raise truck weights from current standard 80,000 pounds to 91,000 pounds on interstates, solely for the stated purpose of gathering safety data on the massive increase.
But we don’t need a decade-long experiment to understand the risks nor turn the people of Utah into human guinea pigs. A 2016 study by the U.S. Department of Transportation already concluded that heavier trucks have significantly higher crash rates — up to 400% higher in some states — and more frequent braking violations.
The other amendment would allow a permanent increase for heavier auto-haulers of 88,000 pounds. These trucks are already among the most dangerous on the road. Expanding their capacity only widens their blind spots and puts every driver at risk just to pack on an extra car.
The escalating danger of heavy-duty transport is reflected in Utah’s recent safety data, which paints a tragic picture. In the most recently compiled data, the state suffered 940 large-truck crashes in 2024, resulting in 401 injuries and 49 tragic deaths, according to data compiled by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
When looking at the decade-long trend from 2014 to 2024, truck crash fatalities in Utah have surged by a massive 172%, underscoring a massive and current public safety crisis that requires urgent attention.
Bigger, heavier trucks will speed up the deterioriation of our state’s roads and bridges, which are already straining. Currently, 37% of Utah’s major roads are rated in poor or mediocre condition, according to an analysis of federal data by TRIP, a nonprofit that focuses on transportation research. For the average driver in our state, this reality hits home in the form of $1.8 billion a year in repair and maintenance costs, or $804 per driver, caused by driving on deteriorated, truck-damaged roads.
Allowing heavier, longer trucks to operate on our local streets only forces taxpayers to subsidize the operations of large freight companies and makes it harder for us to do our jobs.
What’s more, larger commercial trucks become increasingly difficult for drivers to control. More mass not only exacerbates the force of collisions, often involving more vehicles in a single crash, but also frequently leads to more catastrophic post-crash fires that local emergency response teams are forced to handle.
Ultimately, increasing commercial truck size defies common sense. Considering the breadth of research, I urge our representatives in Washington, D.C., to pursue transportation strategy that balances economic development with public safety and the infrastructure needs of our residents.
Utah law enforcement supports sensible transportation solutions, but we must draw a hard line at introducing more risk. We must oppose any effort that puts corporate interests above the safety of our motorists and the state’s struggling roads and bridges. Policy should serve the public, not just the profit margin.
Matt Johnson is the police chief for Spanish Fork.

