×
×
homepage logo

Guest opinion: Questioning Rep. Moore’s judgment for supporting Jim Jordan as speaker

By Kimberly Harris Wagner - | Oct 21, 2023

Like many Americans, I’ve been frustrated with the chaotic situation unfolding in recent weeks in the House of Representatives. With pressing needs both at home and abroad, we need a Speaker of the House so that Congress can do its job. The selected speaker should be a legislator with a track record of problem solving and coalition building. Rep. Jim Jordan does not meet those criteria.

In Congressman Blake Moore’s latest weekly newsletter, he seems to understand that Jordan is a problematic choice but justifies voting for him anyway. He writes that he’d asked two constituents how much they cared about who the next Speaker of the House is. He continues, “They both responded the same way: ‘Maybe I should, but I don’t care at all.'” Moore acknowledges that a sample size of two isn’t meaningful, but by starting his newsletter with this anecdote he implies that the speaker’s identity doesn’t matter to the average American.

I disagree. The Speaker of the House leads Congress. He or she is second in line to the presidency, is responsible for moving legislation through the House, determines which bills can be voted on, becomes a prominent party leader (with the esteem and media attention that a high office entails) and will oversee the certification of the Electoral College vote in the next presidential election.

Jim Jordan, who has never passed a bill in his 16 years in Congress, hasn’t demonstrated that he knows how to get things done, how to compromise, how to reach across the aisle, or how to govern effectively. What he is expert at doing is drawing attention to himself and sowing division. As the founder of the Freedom Caucus, his views and priorities are more extreme than those of most of his colleagues even within the Republican Party. Promoting an extreme and divisive figure to a position of prominence — especially when our nation is already sharply polarized — is shortsighted.

A Speaker of the House, like all members of Congress, swears to uphold the Constitution, which includes supporting free and fair elections. Jordan unabashedly supported President Donald Trump’s attempt to overturn the last election, giving us no reason to believe he wouldn’t be willing to compromise the peaceful transition of power in the future.

In his newsletter, Moore expresses his frustration with the removal of Speaker McCarthy and “the manipulation that was used to do it.” Yet Jordan and his allies are also engaging in a pressure campaign to convince GOP congressional members to support him. That campaign has included intimidation tactics such as threatening to challenge GOP members of Congress in their primary elections next year and posting the office phone numbers of holdouts online to foment a public response. One legislator received death threats for not committing to vote for Jordan, and the spouse of another legislator reported receiving threats as well.

In explaining his support for Jim Jordan, Moore mentions Jordan’s willingness to work with extreme members of the GOP who would not support McCarthy. Moore expresses frustration with this but accepts it as the only way forward. But is it? Wouldn’t it make more sense to find a less-extreme Republican who could secure the support of some Democrats? Bipartisan bridge-building would create positive results for the country, not the least of which would be containing and managing the extreme faction of the GOP.

Moore also suggests that he’s supporting Jordan because of Jordan’s commitment to avoiding a government shutdown and addressing the national debt. I have to imagine there are many members of the GOP who share that commitment but wouldn’t bring so much baggage to this crucial leadership position. Ultimately, real progress on these issues will require collaboration between the parties, and Jordan isn’t the person likely to make that happen.

Despite his obvious reservations about Jordan (including concerns about him voiced by defense personnel), Moore has now voted for Jordan twice to elect him as speaker (as of this writing). Toward the end of his newsletter, Moore says, “I am asking that you all trust me.” Though electing a speaker is urgent business, that urgency shouldn’t require lowering standards to select a speaker with so little to recommend him. I would sincerely like to trust Congressman Moore, but for that he needs to demonstrate that he will put country over party and vote for a speaker who will be both ethical and effective.

Kimberly Harris Wagner has an M.A. in political science and a Ph.D. in organizational behavior, both from UCLA. While raising her family in Fruit Heights, she’s been actively involved in her community, including serving on community councils and volunteering for MWEG (Mormon Women for Ethical Government) and Women’s Work Utah. She ran for the state Legislature last year as a United Utah Party candidate and currently serves on the party’s executive board.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox
I'm interested in (please check all that apply)(Required)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper?(Required)

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today